Sustainability

This Power Firm in the US plans to shutter its Coal Plants by 2028. Finds renewables more competitive

Could this be a sign of things to come? Last Thursday, Northern Indiana Public Service Co. (NIPSCO) presented an analysis for it’s 2018 Integrated Resource Plan (IRP). The company announced during its annual conference that it will be closing most of its coal plants by 2023 and all of them by 2028. The utility firm found that it can save customers more than $4 billion over 30 years by moving from 65% coal today to 15% coal in 5 years and completely phased out over the next ten years. 

NIPSCO’s upcoming IRP is more evidence that coal generation which is on a steady decline everywhere around the world, is following the trend even in the US despite the Trump administration pushback. In Indiana, as elsewhere, the issue is economics. The newest addition to the utility’s generating units was built in 1980 and the analysis found that keeping them on and functioning would be more expensive than replacing them with new wind, solar and storage facilities.

NIPSCO’s current preferred retirement plan “Scenario 6” will see it retire all four units of the Schahfer plant in 2023 and its last coal unit at its Michigan City plant in 2028. [Source: NIPSCO]

NIPSCO, that serves 468,000 electric customers in northern Indiana and has a generation portfolio of ~2,900 MW, of which ~1,800 is from coal said eliminating coal from its portfolio would actually be the cheapest option. However, taking all the Schahfer and Michigan City units offline by 2023 (Scenario 8 above) despite being the lowest resource plan cost, presented “unacceptable” reliability risk to the utility.  

Coal’s inability to compete with renewables remained strong, even when the utility modeled scenarios friendly to the resource. Thanks to the baseload supply issues, a challenge renewables can attack only with the next big breakthrough in storage. The utility analyzed a situation with high natural gas prices, no price on carbon, and a flat fee for delivered coal. 

 

Even in this scenario, retiring coal faster was still cheaper than keeping it around, and the least cost plan was still more expensive to consumers than NIPSCO’s preferred scenario. [Source: NISCO]
NIPSCO proposed a generation mix of 1,500 MW of solar and storage, 150 MW of wind, 125 MW of efficiency and demand-side management and 50 MW of market purchases by 2028, to replace the retiring coal. (Scenario F)

(Scenario F) the plans are based on renewable energy prices NIPSCO received in response to a request for proposals (RFP) earlier this year. [Source: NISCO]
Adding those renewables was also cheaper than building natural gas plants or converting coal facilities to gas, NIPSCO found. “Across all scenarios, converting both Unit 17 and 18 [of Schahfer] would cost NIPSCO customers between $540 [million] to $1.04 [billion] more than retirement and replacement with economically optimized resource selections from the RFP results,” the utility reported.

According to NIPSCO’s preferred plan, it is planning for 1,348 MW of solar Unforced Capacity (UCAP) by 2028. It is not building any new natural gas. And it will reduce GHG emissions by 90% by 2030. NIPSCO’s upcoming IRP represents an acceleration in the global move away from coal and toward renewables. 

Ayush Verma

Ayush is a correspondent at iamrenew.com and writes on renewable energy and sustainability. As an engineering graduate trying to find his niche in the energy journalism segment, he also works as a staff writer for saurenergy.com.

Recent Posts

John Cockerill secures India’s largest electrolyzer supply order from AM Green

AM Green has placed India's largest electrolyzer order with John Cockerill Hydrogen for one of…

1 day ago

Cultivating A Thriving Biofuel Ecosystem: What It Takes To Fuel India’s Green Future

By-Nipun OS  India's energy goals for the next two decades are threefold: achieve energy security,…

3 days ago

India’s biogas sector to offer opportunities for the next 5-10 years: Jan and Anting, Weber Entec

How do you find the Indian CBG market on this visit? What’s the general sentiment?…

4 days ago

BAUR FOLIEN now market leader worldwide; ideally fit for India: MIROSLAV BENKA, MD

MIROSLAV BENKA, MD of BAUR FOLIEN talks to I am Renew and explains its business…

5 days ago

To step-up biogas solutions worldwide, Sistema.bio acquires Inclusive Energy

Biogas developer & innovator, Sistema.bio has acquired Bengaluru headquartered Inclusive Energy (IE) which is at…

5 days ago

ARYA raises 100 crore to develop biogas projects

ARYA, the project development division of GPS Renewables, has secured INR 100 crore in mezzanine…

5 days ago